I know we here at Negative Gamer have discussed Dan “Shoe” Hsu and Crispin Boyer’s Sore Thumbs Blog before. However. it is mainly because it is very reaffirming of the dream that this site was founded on. The whole idea behind Negative Gamer is to take a highly critical look at the games industry and not just be another site that gives developers a digital pat on the back (whether they deserve it or not). Negative Gamer is a place to go when you’re tired of hearing nothing but praise and over inflated scores; a place to make sure that you’re not getting screwed over by a company who cares more about how many units are sold than the quality of the product. Plus, we are the only site where you can get previews of upcoming games in the traditional form of Japanese haiku.
The exposure of what happens in gaming journalism is a real eye opener, both to the average gamer and to a hopeful game blogger like myself. The idea that things can get a bit crooked isn’t terribly surprising to be honest–most American institutions are corrupted in some fashion. We live in a capitalist nation where people are constantly looking out for their own interests. Who’s to say any normal person put in the same situation wouldn’t accept the expensive favors of a company for the cheap price of lower moral standards? We’d all like to think we’d stick to our guns, but unlike the world inside of games there is no clear line between “good” and “evil.”
What is most important about the Sore Thumbs blog is that in some ways, it is encouraging the average gamer to be critical of what they read. No one publication is going to to give you an unbiased view of anything. There are plenty of places to get news on the internet, and a smart gamer will use these resources to find out the real story. By checking out multiple sources and then comparing them to your own, independently formed opinion, you can easily figure out which site offers the most honest views vs the attitude of “giving the people what they want.” In the age where the internet is a primary source for information, gamers no longer have an excuse for standing by while this corruption happens. On the contrary, they should be calling out dishonesty at every possible opportunity.
In some ways it was almost inspiring. I know as a woman writer, I’ll have a somewhat different experience, with different advantages and disadvantages. I take some comfort knowing that while you might need to make some concessions for the sake of business, for the most part you can skim over many of the shady parts of the job and still be successful. I fully intend on protecting my integrity as both a writer and a woman (despite the number of romantic “OMG pic plz” requests on Xbox Live) as I progress into my career. Reading this blog has reminded me that I will always need to be wary of what’s happening around me if I plan on continuing in this industry.
Even without being any sort of famous writer, I’ve had people call my integrity into question with the Guitar Hero: World Tour piece I did a while back. I got some wonderful responses, one in which someone told me I should kill myself. Call me strange but the widely varied feedback made me quite happy. If only people who agree with me comment, then I’m not really changing anything am I? People who understood the point of the site–again, taking a critical look at even the best games–understood what I was saying and responded to it in a generally intelligent way. It made me happy to see that I was causing people to think critically about an aspect of the product that other sites had glossed over and dismissed, even if it was only a minor detail of the game. Plus, I got to hear someone use the phrase “butt trumpet” for the first time.
I think it’s safe to assume and Shoe and Crispin are getting some sense of personal satisfaction out of their blog. They should feel good; they’re asking people to actively think and question the world around them. What they’re doing on their blog is real journalism: giving people facts with minimal bias so that the reader can make the final judgment. In a world where media is constantly trying to tell you what to think, I want to be part of a different breed of writers.
I want to be Benjamin Franklin.
WHAT A TWIST!
By M. Night Shyamalan